DV
Dividend Vision

Investing Metrics

Sortino Ratio

The Sortino ratio is a refinement of the Sharpe ratio that measures return per unit of downside risk only, ignoring the upside swings income investors are happy to keep.

🔵 Intermediate 13 min read Updated November 13, 2026

Definition

The Sortino ratio is a measure of risk-adjusted return that counts only the bad kind of volatility. It is a direct refinement of the Sharpe ratio, and the two formulas look almost identical:

Sortino Ratio = (Portfolio Return − Minimum Acceptable Return) / Downside Deviation

There are three pieces:

  • Portfolio return — the total return of the fund or portfolio over a period, including price change and reinvested distributions.
  • Minimum acceptable return (MAR) — the threshold below which you consider a return a "bad" outcome. Often this is 0, sometimes the risk-free rate, and sometimes a target like your required income yield.
  • Downside deviation — the typical size of the shortfalls below the MAR. Periods at or above the threshold count as zero, so they add no risk.

The one crucial difference from the Sharpe ratio is the denominator. The Sharpe ratio divides by standard deviation, which measures all volatility — a big gain counts against a fund just as much as a big loss. The Sortino ratio divides by downside deviation, which ignores upside swings entirely and penalizes a fund only when it drops below your minimum acceptable return. A higher Sortino ratio means more reward for each unit of harmful volatility.

Why It Matters

Most investors do not lie awake worrying that their fund went up too much. Yet standard deviation — and therefore the Sharpe ratio — treats a surprise 8% monthly gain as exactly as "risky" as a surprise 8% monthly loss. That is mathematically tidy but emotionally and practically backwards. The Sortino ratio fixes this by separating the volatility you fear from the volatility you welcome.

For income and ETF investors this distinction is especially valuable. Many high-yield and dividend-growth strategies are asymmetric: they grind out steady distributions and occasionally jump on a strong month. Under the Sharpe ratio those upside jumps inflate the standard deviation and lower the score, making a perfectly pleasant fund look riskier than it feels to own. The Sortino ratio only reacts to the drawdowns that actually threaten your principal and your income stream, which is what a retiree drawing a paycheck from the portfolio genuinely cares about.

It also complements the other risk numbers rather than replacing them. The Sharpe ratio tells you about efficiency against total variability; beta tells you how sensitive a fund is to the broad market; and the distribution rate tells you the headline income. The Sortino ratio adds the missing piece: reward per unit of downside risk. Reading them together gives a far fuller picture than any single figure.

Formula

The Sortino ratio is written almost exactly like the Sharpe ratio, with one substitution in the denominator:

Sortino = (Rp − MAR) / σdownside

  Rp        = the portfolio or fund return over the period,
              including price change and reinvested distributions
  MAR       = minimum acceptable return — the target you treat as
              "good enough" (often 0, sometimes the risk-free rate,
              sometimes a required income yield)
  σdownside = downside deviation — the root-mean-square of the
              shortfalls BELOW the MAR; a period at or above it
              contributes zero but still counts in the average

The numerator, Rp − MAR, is the excess return over your threshold: how much the fund beat, or missed, the bar you set. That mirrors the Sharpe ratio's Rp − Rf exactly. The denominator is where the two part ways. The Sharpe ratio divides by standard deviation, which squares every period's distance from the average — so a surprise gain inflates it just as much as an equal-sized loss. Downside deviation instead squares only the shortfalls below the MAR and treats every above-target period as zero:

σdownside = sqrt( (1 / N) × Σ [ min(0, Ri − MAR) ]² )

  N   = total number of periods
  Ri  = the return in period i

A tiny worked calculation. Take six monthly returns — 3%, 2%, −1%, 4%, −3%, 1% — with a MAR of 0%. Only the two negative months fall below the target, so only they contribute to the sum:

  • Shortfalls, min(0, Ri − MAR): 0, 0, −1%, 0, −3%, 0
  • Squared: 0, 0, 1, 0, 9, 0 — which add up to 10
  • Divide by N = 6 (≈ 1.67), then take the square root: ≈ 1.29%

The ordinary standard deviation of those same six months, also dividing by N, is about 2.38% (2.61% with the sample N − 1 divisor), because it also counts how far the four good months sat from the average. Downside deviation is barely half as large here — and that gap is the entire point: it strips out the upside volatility that was quietly padding the Sharpe ratio's denominator.

Example

Consider two funds income investors frequently weigh against each other: SCHD, a low-cost dividend-growth ETF, and JEPI, an equity premium income (covered-call) fund, plus the S&P 500 index fund VOO for contrast. Covered-call funds like JEPI (and the Nasdaq-100 option-income fund QQQI, from NEOS) sell call options, which caps their upside — they hand away the biggest up-months in exchange for option premium. That capped upside is exactly where Sharpe and Sortino diverge.

The figures below are hypothetical, the same ones the Sharpe ratio guide uses, with a downside deviation added for each fund. Suppose over a given year they work out like this, with a minimum acceptable return of 4%:

  • SCHD returns 10%, with total standard deviation of 14% but downside deviation of only 8% — its volatility is lopsided toward good months.
  • JEPI returns 9%, with total standard deviation of 9% and downside deviation of 8% — its swings are small, but because the covered-call overlay caps the upside, nearly all of the volatility that remains is downside volatility: its downside deviation (8%) sits close to its total deviation (9%).
  • VOO returns 12%, with total standard deviation of 16% but downside deviation of only 10% — an uncapped index fund keeps its biggest up-months, so much of its volatility shows up as good months rather than deep drawdowns.

Run the Sharpe ratios first:

  1. SCHD: (10% − 4%) / 14% = 0.43
  2. JEPI: (9% − 4%) / 9% = 0.56
  3. VOO: (12% − 4%) / 16% = 0.50

By Sharpe, JEPI wins — its low total volatility flatters it. Now run Sortino:

  1. SCHD: (10% − 4%) / 8% = 0.75
  2. JEPI: (9% − 4%) / 8% = 0.63
  3. VOO: (12% − 4%) / 10% = 0.80

Line the three funds up side by side:

FundSharpeSortinoTakeaway
SCHD0.430.75Upside-skewed volatility — Sortino rewards what Sharpe punishes.
JEPI0.560.63Capped upside leaves little good volatility, so the Sortino edge shrinks.
VOO0.500.80Volatile, but mostly to the upside — top downside-adjusted score.

The verdict flips. Once you stop punishing SCHD for its cheerful up-months and measure only the downside, SCHD delivered more return per unit of harmful risk than JEPI, and VOO moves to the top. JEPI's advantage under Sharpe was partly an artifact of a covered-call strategy that rarely surprises you to the upside — so it has little "good volatility" for the Sharpe ratio to penalize in the first place. This is the classic pattern: capped-upside income funds with little upside surprise score relatively better on Sharpe than on Sortino, while funds with asymmetric, upside-skewed returns look better on Sortino than on Sharpe.

Real funds show a milder version of the same thing. Over the three years to November 12, 2026, our JEPI vs SCHD page showed SCHD's Sortino ratio at about 1.6 against JEPI's about 0.9 (Sharpe: about 1.1 against 0.6), and on SCHD vs VOO VOO's at about 1.4. JEPI's Sortino ran about 1.4 times its Sharpe, SCHD's about 1.5 times: the capped fund gained the least from the switch, though the gap is far smaller than in the hypothetical above. A different window can change the order.

Where to Find a Fund's Sortino Ratio

Fact sheets that report a Sortino ratio rarely state their MAR, which is the first thing to check. Dividend Vision measures all funds the same way: daily total returns (distributions reinvested), with the MAR set to the current 3-month T-bill yield, which is applied across the whole window. Downside deviation averages the squared daily shortfalls below that rate over all days in the window, including the days with no shortfall, and is annualized with √252:

  • ETF screener. The screener has a Sortino column and filter for 1-year, 3-year, and since-inception windows.
  • Compare pages. Each compare page, such as JEPI vs SCHD, lists Sortino beside Sharpe, volatility, and maximum drawdown over one shared window: the trailing three years, or the trailing year when a fund is younger than that.
  • Your portfolio. The dashboard can show a Sortino ratio for your current holdings, replayed as a monthly-rebalanced basket over up to three years. It uses monthly returns annualized with √12, so it is not on quite the same basis as a fund's screener figure (how it is calculated). If no month in the window fell below the T-bill rate, downside deviation is zero and the dashboard shows "No downside in window" instead of a number.

A fund with less than about a year of history shows no Sortino ratio rather than a misleading one; the dashboard likewise needs at least 12 months of history.

Common Mistakes

  • Comparing Sortino ratios computed with different MARs. The minimum acceptable return is a free parameter. One fact sheet may use zero, another the T-bill rate, another a 6% income target. Change the MAR and the ratio changes — so two Sortino numbers are only comparable if they share the same threshold.
  • Comparing across different time periods. Like every risk-adjusted metric, a Sortino ratio measured in a calm year looks far better than one measured through a drawdown. Only compare funds over the same window.
  • Treating it as a standalone verdict. A high Sortino ratio does not tell you a fund's expense ratio, its tax treatment, how much of the distribution is return of capital, or whether it fits your goals. It is one input, not a buy signal.
  • Assuming Sortino always beats Sharpe. It is not "the better ratio," just a different lens. For a symmetric, broadly diversified fund the two often tell nearly the same story; the gap only widens when returns are skewed.
  • Trusting a ratio built from too little, or too coarse, data. Downside deviation needs enough below-target periods to mean anything. Estimate it from a handful of annual returns, or from a single calm year, and you will capture almost no drawdowns — starving the denominator and inflating the ratio. Monthly or daily data spanning a full market cycle gives a far more honest downside picture; it is the same sampling caveat that applies to the Sharpe ratio.
  • Chasing tiny differences. A Sortino ratio of 0.75 versus 0.72 is noise. Use it to separate clearly efficient funds from clearly inefficient ones, not to split hairs.

FAQ

What is a good Sortino ratio?

As a rough guide, a Sortino ratio below 1.0 is considered sub-par, 1.0 to 2.0 is good, 2.0 to 3.0 is very good, and above 3.0 is excellent. Because it ignores upside volatility, a fund that beat its MAR usually has a Sortino ratio higher than its Sharpe ratio, so do not compare the two numbers head-to-head against the same threshold. As always, compare a fund against its peers over the same time frame and using the same minimum acceptable return rather than against a fixed cutoff.

Sortino vs Sharpe — which is better?

Neither is universally better; they answer different questions. The Sharpe ratio rewards funds for low total volatility, which suits investors who dislike surprises in either direction. The Sortino ratio rewards funds for low downside volatility only, which suits income investors who are happy to keep upside surprises. For funds with lopsided, upside-skewed returns the Sortino ratio is often the fairer measure; for symmetric funds the two usually agree.

What is downside deviation?

Downside deviation is the statistic that makes the Sortino ratio different from the Sharpe ratio. It is a standard-deviation-style measure of volatility, but only shortfalls below your minimum acceptable return add to it; a period at or above the target counts as zero, though it still counts toward the number of periods. The result is a single number, in the same units as your returns, that captures how hard a fund tends to move against you. The Formula section above walks through the exact calculation with a worked six-month example.

What MAR should I use?

The minimum acceptable return is a choice, and the best one depends on the question you are asking. Set it to 0% if you simply want to penalize losing money. Use the risk-free rate — a short T-bill yield — if you want a true "excess return" number comparable to the Sharpe ratio; this is what Dividend Vision uses. Use your required income yield or spending target if you are a retiree who cares whether the fund clears the bar you actually live on. None of these is "correct" in the abstract, but whichever you choose, apply the same MAR to every fund you compare — changing the threshold changes the ratio.

Can the Sortino ratio be negative?

Yes. A negative Sortino ratio means the fund's return fell below your minimum acceptable return over the period — the numerator is negative. It does not necessarily mean the fund lost money in absolute terms; it can simply mean the return failed to clear the threshold you set, whether that threshold is zero, the risk-free rate, or an income target.

Why is downside deviation different from standard deviation?

Standard deviation measures how far all returns spread around their average, so a big gain and a big loss both increase it. Downside deviation only measures how far returns fall below the minimum acceptable return, treating each above-threshold period as zero risk. That is why two funds can share the same standard deviation but have very different downside deviations if one's volatility is concentrated in good months rather than bad ones.

Related metrics & articles

Explore this topic

Apply this concept: research candidates, then run your own numbers.

Explore related funds

Funds discussed in this article, plus a pre-filtered screen and the Dividend tag hub for finding more like them.

📊 Model Portfolios

See this lesson in a real portfolio

Browse all model portfolios

Was this lesson helpful?

Put it into practice

Dividend Vision turns these concepts into numbers for your own holdings.