DV
Dividend Vision

ETF Comparison

VCR vs XLY: Which Is the Better Pick in 2026?

A head-to-head comparison of Vanguard Consumer Discretionary ETF and Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund covering yield, cost, risk, and income potential.

Data updated September 4, 2026

Best for

  • VCRInvestors who want broad equity exposure.
  • XLYInvestors who want broad equity exposure.

Jump to the side-by-side numbers

Visual comparison

Key metrics

Projected income on $10K

Projections assume the current yield and share price remain constant. Actual results will vary.

Total returns

VCR has outpaced XLY over the trailing twelve months, posting a 1.62% total return against 0.29%. The lead holds up over 10 years too: VCR has compounded at 13.07% a year, against 12.16% for XLY. Figures are total returns: price change plus every distribution reinvested.

Total return and risk statistics by fund. Each row is one fund; each column is one period or statistic.
SymbolYTD1Y3Y5Y10YSince Jan 2004Volatility Sharpe Sortino Max drawdown
VCR-0.72%1.62%11.65%4.80%13.07%10.88%21.3%0.310.44-27.4%
XLY-2.51%0.29%11.53%5.46%12.16%10.54%21.0%0.310.44-26.0%

Total return with all distributions reinvested on the ex-dividend date (a modeling convention, not the cash-settlement date), split-adjusted, as of September 4, 2026. YTD and 1Y are cumulative; windows of one year or longer are annualized. “Since Jan 2004” measures every fund from January 30, 2004 — the youngest fund's first trading day — so all funds share one comparison window. Volatility is the annualized standard deviation of daily total returns over the trailing 3 years. Sharpe and Sortino divide the annualized return in excess of the risk-free rate by, respectively, that volatility and the downside deviation (both over the trailing 3 years) — higher is better. Max drawdown is the largest peak-to-trough total-return decline over the same window — shallower is better.

Side-by-side snapshot

Side-by-side snapshot. Each row is one metric; each column is one fund.
MetricVCRXLY
Full nameVanguard Consumer Discretionary ETFConsumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund
IssuerVanguardState Street
Underlying indexMSCI US Investable Market Consumer Discretionary 25/50 IndexConsumer Discretionary Select Sector Index
Last Close$387.34 as of September 4, 2026$114.91 as of September 4, 2026
Distribution yield0.73%0.81%
Distribution Safety Score™ 6996
Safety-Adjusted Yield 0.50%0.78%
Expense ratio0.09%0.08%
AUM$5.93B$22.9B
Distribution frequencyQuarterlyQuarterly
ObjectiveTracks the MSCI US Investable Market Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index.Tracks the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index from the S&P 500.
Asset classEquityEquity
Inception date01/26/200412/16/1998
Beta1.21.14
Last dividend$0.707$0.233
Ex-dividend date06/24/202606/22/2026

Bottom lineVCR and XLY are both for investors who want broad equity exposure — so strategy isn't the deciding factor here. Fees and payouts are close too, so it comes down to which your broker offers commission-free and any share-price or tax-lot preference.

Model this comparison:
Compare in my portfolio Forecast income Save to watchlist

Income calculator

See how much monthly income a hypothetical investment would generate in each ETF at current yields.

Vanguard
ETFs116
Total AUM$4650B

ETFs and AUM reflect what Dividend Vision tracks — the issuer's full lineup may be larger.

Vanguard is one of the largest and most established ETF issuers, known for low-cost, broadly diversified fund offerings built on passive indexing principles. Their lineup spans multiple asset classes and strategies, including core equity and bond index funds, dividend-focused portfolios, ESG-screened options, factor-based strategies, sector exposure, target-date retirement funds, and international investments across developed and emerging markets. The platform is characterized by its emphasis on accessibility and cost efficiency across a comprehensive range of fund families, serving both individual investors seeking broad market exposure and those pursuing specific income, sustainability, or thematic objectives.

See our curated list of related YouTube videos on VCR.

See all Vanguard ETFs
State Street
ETFs179
Total AUM$2124B

ETFs and AUM reflect what Dividend Vision tracks — the issuer's full lineup may be larger.

State Street Global Advisors (SSGA) is one of the largest ETF providers globally, known for its flagship SPDR suite of exchange-traded products that serve both institutional and retail investors across a broad range of asset classes. Their 88-fund lineup spans diverse strategies including sector exposure (Select Sector SPDR), income generation (Income and Select Sector SPDR Premium Income families), commodities (including the widely-held GLD gold ETF), bonds, ESG-focused investments, and thematic allocations, with popular tickers like DIA (Diamonds Trust), FEZ (Eurozone exposure), and JNK (high-yield bonds) among their most recognized funds. The issuer is characterized by its comprehensive coverage across multiple market segments and its emphasis on both traditional index-based products and specialized strategies like covered call income funds and factor-based investing.

See our curated list of related YouTube videos on XLY.

See all State Street ETFs

Want to go deeper?

Add these ETFs to a sample portfolio and forecast your dividend income over 5+ years — free to start, no credit card.

Compare in my portfolio Forecast income Save to watchlist

Quick verdict

VCR (Vanguard Consumer Discretionary ETF) and XLY (Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund) are both quarterly-pay dividend ETFs, but they take different approaches.

XLY offers the higher yield at 0.81% vs 0.73% for VCR. A higher yield means more current income per dollar invested, though it may come with different risk characteristics.

XLY is cheaper with an expense ratio of 0.08% compared to 0.09%.

They have different reference exposures: VCR is linked to MSCI US Investable Market Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index while XLY is linked to Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index, which means their performance drivers differ.

XLY is the larger fund by assets ($22.9B), which generally means tighter spreads and better liquidity.

Deep dive

Yield & income

On a $10,000 investment, VCR would generate roughly $6.08/month, while XLY would produce $6.75/month, at current distribution rates. Both pay quarterly distributions.

VCR yield0.73%
XLY yield0.81%
Monthly diff on $10K$0.67

Cost & efficiency

Over 10 years on $10,000, VCR would cost approximately $90 in fees vs $80 for XLY (simplified, not compounded). The $10.00 difference may be offset by yield or performance.

VCR ER0.09%
XLY ER0.08%

Strategy & risk

VCR tracks MSCI US Investable Market Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, while XLY tracks Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index. Beta is 1.2 for VCR and 1.14 for XLY, making XLY the less volatile of the two by this measure.

VCR beta1.2
XLY beta1.14

Fund details

VCR is managed by Vanguard (launched 01/26/2004) with $5.93B in assets. XLY is managed by State Street (launched 12/16/1998) with $22.9B in assets.

VCR AUM$5.93B
XLY AUM$22.9B
Ready to act?
Open in Comparator Model in portfolio See pricing

Enjoyed this page?

Do us a favor — if you found this comparison useful, please share it with a friend researching dividend ETFs.

Frequently asked questions

What is the current distribution yield for VCR and XLY?

VCR currently distributes 0.73% and XLY 0.81%, based on fund data updated September 2026. Distribution yield moves with both the payout and the share price, so check the as-of date before relying on either figure.

Is VCR or XLY better for dividend income?

It depends on your goals. XLY currently offers the higher distribution yield, which means more income per dollar invested. However, a lower-yield fund may offer better total return or lower volatility. Consider your time horizon and risk tolerance.

What is the difference between VCR and XLY?

VCR (Vanguard Consumer Discretionary ETF) tracks MSCI US Investable Market Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, while XLY (Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund) tracks Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index. They are issued by Vanguard and State Street respectively.

Can I hold both VCR and XLY?

Yes — nothing prevents holding both. Whether the combination actually diversifies depends on how much the underlying exposures overlap, which isn't fully measurable from the data on this page; review each security's holdings, sector, and strategy before treating them as complementary.

Is VCR or XLY safer?

By Dividend Vision's Distribution Safety Score — a rules-based 0–100 estimate of how resilient a distribution looks, where higher is safer — XLY scores 96, VCR scores 69, so XLY's payout currently looks the more resilient of the two. No score makes an investment risk-free — treat this as a screening signal, not a guarantee.

Which has lower fees, VCR or XLY?

VCR has an expense ratio of 0.09% while XLY charges 0.08%. Lower fees mean more of your investment returns stay in your pocket over time.

How much income does $10,000 in VCR vs XLY generate?

At current rates, $10,000 in VCR would generate roughly $6.08 per month ($73.00 annually). The same in XLY would produce about $6.75 per month ($81.00 annually).

Which has performed better historically, VCR or XLY?

VCR has outpaced XLY over the trailing twelve months, posting a 1.62% total return against 0.29%. The lead holds up over 10 years too: VCR has compounded at 13.07% a year, against 12.16% for XLY. Figures are total returns: price change plus every distribution reinvested. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

More comparisons to explore

VCR vs XLY — at a glance

Generated August 29, 2026.

Overview

VCR and XLY are both index-tracking ETFs focused on consumer discretionary stocks, but they capture different slices of the market. VCR follows the MSCI US Investable Market Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, which includes the full breadth of the investable market across the sector. XLY tracks the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index, limiting itself to the discretionary component of the S&P 500. This means XLY holds only the largest-cap discretionary names, while VCR extends further down the market-cap spectrum.

How they differ

The core difference is index construction: XLY holds only S&P 500 consumer discretionary stocks, making it a large-cap play; VCR encompasses the broader investable market including mid-caps and smaller names through the MSCI index. XLY is substantially larger with $22.9B in AUM versus VCR's $5.93B, and has been around longer (since 1998 vs. 2004). Both offer similar yields—XLY at 0.81% and VCR at 0.73%—with XLY charging a marginally lower expense ratio of 0.08% to VCR's 0.09%. Beta-wise, VCR at 1.2 is more volatile than XLY at 1.14, reflecting the inclusion of smaller, more reactive holdings in VCR's broader index.

Who each is best for

VCR: Fits investors seeking broad exposure to the entire consumer discretionary sector and willing to accept higher volatility for access to mid-cap and smaller discretionary names alongside mega-cap retailers and automakers.

XLY: Designed for investors preferring a large-cap-only approach to discretionary spending, with the added benefit of lower volatility and a more established, heavily-traded fund structure.

Key risks to know

  • Index concentration in mega-cap names: Both funds are heavily weighted toward the largest consumer discretionary companies (Amazon, Tesla, Home Depot, etc.), meaning sector-wide moves in mega-cap consumer stocks dominate performance regardless of which index is tracked.
  • Economic sensitivity: Consumer discretionary stocks are cyclically sensitive to changes in consumer confidence, employment, and credit availability. Both VCR and XLY will underperform in economic downturns when consumers pull back spending.
  • Breadth vs. concentration tradeoff: VCR's broader index exposure introduces smaller-company idiosyncratic risk that XLY avoids by sticking to the S&P 500; conversely, XLY's tighter focus means less diversification across company sizes and niche discretionary subsectors.
  • Beta differential: VCR's higher beta of 1.2 versus XLY's 1.14 means it will amplify market moves in both directions, particularly during volatile periods.

Bottom line

If you want exposure across the full market-cap spectrum of discretionary stocks and can tolerate higher volatility, VCR offers broader diversification. If you prefer the stability of large-cap-only exposure with a slightly lower expense ratio and larger fund size, XLY reflects a different construction philosophy. Past performance does not guarantee future returns; the choice hinges on which sector composition and volatility profile aligns with your portfolio goals.

AI-generated analysis for educational purposes only. Verify important details independently; past performance does not guarantee future results.

Learn the method

The metrics behind this comparison, explained in the Academy.

How to read a fund's stats How expense ratios eat returns Correlation between two funds

Still deciding? Compare them against your own portfolio

See how each ETF fits alongside your real holdings — forecast future income, analyze overlap, and gauge risk. Start a free 7-day Dividend Vision trial and make the call with your full portfolio in view.

Start Free Open in Comparator Browse Screener