DV
Dividend Vision

Security Comparison

FXAIX vs SPY: Same Index, Different Wrapper

A head-to-head of Fidelity's 500 Index Fund and the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust covering expense, trading mechanics, and account fit — not two markets.

Updated November 17, 2026

How these figures are calculated: methodology.

Price and total return

Compare the same available dates. Add a ticker or benchmark below; these controls change the chart only. The snapshot and article describe the original comparison.

Interactive history loads here. The snapshot and period returns remain available when chart history cannot be loaded.

Distribution Safety Score™

An estimate of distribution reliability, not price or principal safety, a probability, or a guarantee. Score methodology.

FXAIX

100/ 100

Safe

High confidence

SPY

100/ 100

Safe

High confidence

Score snapshot as of .

Side-by-side snapshot

Side-by-side snapshot. Each row is one metric; each column is one fund.
MetricFXAIXSPY
Full nameFidelity 500 Index FundSPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust
IssuerFidelity InvestmentsState Street
Last Close$255.33 as of November 17, 2026$732.44 as of November 17, 2026
Distribution rate1.06%1.03%
Trailing 12-month yield1.10%1.04%
Distribution Safety Score™ 100100
Safety-Adjusted Yield 1.06%1.03%
Expense ratio0.015%0.0945%
AUM$851B$785B
Distribution frequencyQuarterlyQuarterly
Underlying indexS&P 500 IndexS&P 500 Index
Objective—Track the S&P 500 Index before expenses.
Asset classEquityEquity
Inception date02/17/198801/22/1993
Beta0.970.97
Last dividend$0.713$1.89
Ex-dividend date10/02/202609/18/2026

Total returns

100% reinvested · ex-date convention. Period returns use this fixed assumption, independent of chart settings. YTD and 1Y are cumulative period returns; 3Y, 5Y, and 10Y are annualized. The shared Since-start window is annualized only when it covers at least one year.

FXAIX has outpaced SPY over the trailing twelve months, posting a 11.27% total return against 11.22%. The lead holds up over 10 years too: FXAIX has compounded at 14.76% a year, against 14.63% for SPY. Figures are total returns: price change plus every distribution reinvested.

Total return and risk statistics by fund. Each row is one fund; each column is one period or statistic.
SymbolYTD cumulative1Y cumulative3Y annualized5Y annualized10Y annualizedSince May 2011Volatility Sharpe Sortino Max drawdown
FXAIX8.29%11.27%19.20%10.99%14.76%13.55%15.2%0.881.26-18.5%
SPY8.25%11.22%18.99%10.84%14.63%13.43%15.4%0.861.23-18.8%

Total return with all distributions reinvested on the ex-dividend date (a modeling convention, not the cash-settlement date), split-adjusted, as of November 17, 2026. YTD and 1Y are cumulative period returns; 3Y, 5Y, and 10Y are annualized. The shared Since-start window is annualized only when it covers at least one year. “Since May 2011” measures every fund from May 10, 2011 — the start of shared available history — so all funds share one comparison window. Volatility is the annualized standard deviation of daily total returns over the trailing 3 years. Sharpe and Sortino divide the annualized return in excess of the risk-free rate by, respectively, that volatility and the downside deviation (both over the trailing 3 years) — higher is better. Max drawdown is the largest peak-to-trough total-return decline over the same window — shallower is better.

Visual comparison

Key metrics

Projected income on $10K

Projections assume the current yield and share price remain constant. Actual results will vary.

Bottom lineFXAIX and SPY are nearly interchangeable — both track the S&P 500 with very similar cost and risk. The clearest tie-breaker is cost: FXAIX is cheaper at 0.015% vs 0.0945%.

FXAIX vs SPY: mutual fund or the original ETF?

Same S&P 500. FXAIX trades at end-of-day NAV inside Fidelity. SPY trades all day as a unit investment trust. Wrapper and cost are the decision.

FXAIXSPY
VehicleIndex mutual fundUnit investment trust ETF
TradingEnd-of-day net asset valueIntraday at a market price
Expense ratio0.015%0.0945%
Distribution rate1.06%1.03%

Income calculator

See how much monthly income a hypothetical investment would generate in each security at current yields.

ETFs186
Total AUM$2.13T

ETFs and AUM reflect what Dividend Vision tracks — the issuer's full lineup may be larger.

State Street Global Advisors (SSGA) is one of the largest ETF providers globally, known for pioneering broad-based index and sector exposure through its SPDR product family. Their lineup spans multiple strategies including traditional index funds, income-focused offerings, factor-based approaches, ESG solutions, thematic investments, commodities, bonds, and alternatives, serving both core portfolio building and specialized investment needs. With an extensive range of tickers covering domestic equities, international markets, sector exposure, and fixed income, State Street maintains a comprehensive product ecosystem that appeals to both individual and institutional investors seeking diversified ETF options.

See our curated list of related YouTube videos on SPY.

Quick verdict

FXAIX (Fidelity 500 Index Fund) is a mutual fund, while SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust) is an ETF — their trading structures differ.

FXAIX offers the higher yield at 1.06% vs 1.03% for SPY. A higher yield means more current income per dollar invested, though it may come with different risk characteristics.

FXAIX is cheaper with an expense ratio of 0.015% compared to 0.0945%.

FXAIX is the larger fund by assets ($851B), but assets alone do not establish trading costs or liquidity.

Top-holdings overlap

Overlap unavailable. Some disclosed holdings for FXAIX lack security identifiers. Reliable holdings are needed before calculating overlap.

Deep dive

Yield & income

On a $10,000 investment at current distribution rates, FXAIX would pay about $106.00 a year (about $26.50 per quarterly distribution), while SPY would pay about $103.00 a year (about $25.75 per quarterly distribution). Both pay quarterly distributions.

FXAIX yield1.06%
SPY yield1.03%
Annual cash diff on $10K$3.00

Cost & efficiency

Over 10 years on $10,000, FXAIX would cost approximately $15 in fees vs $95 for SPY (simplified, not compounded). The $79.50 difference may be offset by yield or performance.

FXAIX ER0.015%
SPY ER0.0945%

Strategy & risk

Both FXAIX and SPY wrap S&P 500 Index with similar strategies (mutual fund and large cap). The practical differences are yield target, fee structure, and issuer track record — not the underlying mechanic.

FXAIX beta0.97
SPY beta0.97

Fund details

FXAIX is managed by Fidelity Investments (launched 02/17/1988) with $851B in assets. SPY is managed by State Street (launched 01/22/1993) with $785B in assets.

FXAIX AUM$851B
SPY AUM$785B

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between FXAIX and SPY?

Same S&P 500 index, different wrapper. FXAIX (Fidelity 500 Index Fund) is a Fidelity index mutual fund that transacts at end-of-day net asset value. SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust) is a unit investment trust that trades all day at a market price. Cost is 0.015% versus 0.0945%; distributions are 1.06% and 1.03% as of November 2026. Performance gaps are mostly cost and structure, not two different markets. FXAIX is a mutual fund, not an exchange-traded fund.

What is the current distribution rate for FXAIX and SPY?

FXAIX currently distributes 1.06% and SPY 1.03%, based on fund data updated November 2026. Distribution rate moves with both the payout and the share price, so check the as-of date before relying on either figure.

Is FXAIX or SPY better for dividend income?

It depends on your goals. FXAIX currently offers the higher distribution yield, which means more income per dollar invested. However, a lower-yield fund may offer better total return or lower volatility. Consider your time horizon and risk tolerance.

Can I hold both FXAIX and SPY?

You can, but expect significant overlap. Both funds use similar strategies on S&P 500 Index, so holding them together gives you two wrappers around effectively the same exposure — not true diversification. Weigh issuer, fee, and yield differences rather than treating them as complementary.

Is FXAIX or SPY safer?

By Dividend Vision's Distribution Safety Score — a rules-based 0–100 estimate of how resilient a distribution looks, where higher is safer — they are effectively tied: FXAIX scores 100, SPY scores 100. Neither has a clear safety edge on that measure. No score makes an investment risk-free — treat this as a screening signal, not a guarantee.

Which has lower fees, FXAIX or SPY?

FXAIX has an expense ratio of 0.015% while SPY charges 0.0945%. Lower fees mean more of your investment returns stay in your pocket over time.

How much income does $10,000 in FXAIX vs SPY generate?

At current distribution rates, $10,000 in FXAIX would pay about $106.00 a year (about $26.50 per quarterly distribution). $10,000 in SPY would pay about $103.00 a year (about $25.75 per quarterly distribution).

Which has performed better historically, FXAIX or SPY?

FXAIX has outpaced SPY over the trailing twelve months, posting a 11.27% total return against 11.22%. The lead holds up over 10 years too: FXAIX has compounded at 14.76% a year, against 14.63% for SPY. Figures are total returns: price change plus every distribution reinvested. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

More comparisons to explore

FXAIX vs SPY — at a glance

Generated November 14, 2026.

Overview

FXAIX and SPY both track the S&P 500 Index and hold nearly identical large-cap U.S. equity exposure. Both charge minimal fees, but they differ in cost, tax efficiency, and how investors buy and sell them.

How they differ

The biggest distinction is cost. FXAIX's expense ratio of 0.015% undercuts SPY's 0.0945% by 79.5 basis points—a meaningful gap on a $1 million position over a decade. SPY trades on an exchange like a stock, which means intraday price discovery and tighter bid-ask spreads for active traders, while FXAIX transacts at end-of-day NAV without a spread. The distribution yield is also marginally different: FXAIX pays 1.06% while SPY yields 1.03%, a 8 basis point gap that likely reflects expense drag.

Who each is best for

  • FXAIX: Fits buy-and-hold investors planning long-term index exposure through a brokerage or retirement account where they can transact at NAV; the lower expense ratio compounds meaningfully over decades.
  • SPY: Designed for investors who trade actively during market hours, want tight intraday execution, or prefer the fungibility and ease of exchange-listed securities; also common in systematic or algorithmic portfolios that benefit from ETF structure.

Key risks to know

  • Index concentration risk: Both funds hold the S&P 500, so large-cap stocks—especially technology and financials—dominate the portfolio. Any sharp downturn in mega-cap equities will hit both funds hard and in the same way.
  • Beta sensitivity: Both securities have a beta of 0.97, meaning they amplify market swings nearly one-to-one. A broad equity bear market will drive proportional declines in NAV.
  • Fee drag differential: Although both expense ratios are low, the 79.5 basis point gap favors FXAIX over long holding periods, particularly if SPY trades incur bid-ask spreads or market-hours timing costs that aren't captured in the expense ratio.

Bottom line

If you prioritize the absolute lowest cost and plan to buy and hold for years, FXAIX's 0.015% expense ratio offers a structural edge. If you value intraday trading flexibility or need the simplicity of an exchange-listed security, SPY's liquidity and ticker recognition may justify its modestly higher 0.0945% fee. Both track the same index with nearly identical beta, so the choice hinges on convenience, trading pattern, and how fees compound over your time horizon. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

AI-generated analysis for educational purposes only. Verify important details independently; past performance does not guarantee future results.

Learn the method

The metrics behind this comparison, explained in the Academy.

Continue your research

Tracking requires a free account. Account features · Plans.

These comparisons follow the Dividend Vision methodology.