DV
Dividend Vision

ETF Comparison

SPY vs SPYI: Which Is the Better Pick in 2026?

A head-to-head comparison of SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust and NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF covering yield, cost, risk, and income potential.

Updated November 17, 2026

How these figures are calculated: methodology.

Best for

  • SPYInvestors who want simple, diversified core exposure in one low-cost fund.
  • SPYIInvestors who want to maximize current income — roughly 12.11%, generated by selling options premium.

Jump to the side-by-side numbers

Price and total return

Compare the same available dates. Add a ticker or benchmark below; these controls change the chart only. The snapshot and article describe the original comparison.

Interactive history loads here. The snapshot and period returns remain available when chart history cannot be loaded.

Distribution Safety Score™

An estimate of distribution reliability, not price or principal safety, a probability, or a guarantee. Score methodology.

SPY

100/ 100

Safe

High confidence

SPYI

90/ 100

Safe

Limited data

Score snapshot as of .

Side-by-side snapshot

Side-by-side snapshot. Each row is one metric; each column is one fund.
MetricSPYSPYI
Full nameSPDR S&P 500 ETF TrustNEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF
IssuerState StreetNEOS
Last Close$732.44 as of November 17, 2026$51.12 as of November 17, 2026
Distribution rate1.03%12.11%
Trailing 12-month yield1.04%13.38%
30-day SEC yield—0.48%
Distribution Safety Score™ 10090
Safety-Adjusted Yield 1.03%10.90%
Expense ratio0.0945%0.68%
AUM$785B$12.5B
Distribution frequencyQuarterlyMonthly
Underlying indexS&P 500 IndexS&P 500 Index
ObjectiveTrack the S&P 500 Index before expenses.Seeks to generate high monthly income in a tax efficient manner while targeting equity appreciation.
Asset classEquityEquity
Inception date01/22/199308/29/2022
Beta0.970.67
Last dividend$1.89$0.516 declared, pays 11/20/2026
Ex-dividend date09/18/202611/18/2026 upcoming

Total returns

100% reinvested · ex-date convention. Period returns use this fixed assumption, independent of chart settings. YTD and 1Y are cumulative period returns; 3Y, 5Y, and 10Y are annualized. The shared Since-start window is annualized only when it covers at least one year.

SPY has outpaced SPYI over the trailing twelve months, posting a 11.22% total return against 11.10%. The lead holds up over 3 years too: SPY has compounded at 18.99% a year, against 15.40% for SPYI. Figures are total returns: price change plus every distribution reinvested.

Total return and risk statistics by fund. Each row is one fund; each column is one period or statistic.
SymbolYTD cumulative1Y cumulative3Y annualizedSince Aug 2022Volatility Sharpe Sortino Max drawdown
SPY8.25%11.22%18.99%17.09%15.4%0.861.23-18.8%
SPYI7.55%11.10%15.40%13.74%12.7%0.801.12-16.5%

Total return with all distributions reinvested on the ex-dividend date (a modeling convention, not the cash-settlement date), split-adjusted, as of November 17, 2026. YTD and 1Y are cumulative period returns; 3Y, 5Y, and 10Y are annualized. The shared Since-start window is annualized only when it covers at least one year. “Since Aug 2022” measures every fund from August 30, 2022 — the start of shared available history — so all funds share one comparison window. Volatility is the annualized standard deviation of daily total returns over the trailing 3 years. Sharpe and Sortino divide the annualized return in excess of the risk-free rate by, respectively, that volatility and the downside deviation (both over the trailing 3 years) — higher is better. Max drawdown is the largest peak-to-trough total-return decline over the same window — shallower is better.

Distribution rate and SEC yield

MetricSPYSPYI
Forward distribution rate1.03%12.11%
Trailing 12-month yield1.04%13.38%
30-day SEC yield—0.48%

Total return (price change plus reinvested distributions) is the Total returns section above. A 30-day SEC yield can sit far from the headline distribution rate; both numbers are the fund's own published fields.

Visual comparison

Key metrics

Projected income on $10K

Projections assume the current yield and share price remain constant. Actual results will vary.

Bottom lineChoose SPY if you want simple, diversified core exposure in one low-cost fund. Choose SPYI if you want to maximize current income — roughly 12.11%, generated by selling options premium. There's no free lunch: SPYI's payout comes from selling options, which caps upside and can erode the share price over time, while SPY keeps full price exposure.

How the risk works

Read this before the income numbers below: the strategy mechanics on this page shape what those payouts can cost you.

  • Capped upside and premium dependence. SPYI generates income by selling options, which trades away part of a strong rally in exchange for premium. Distributions can include return of capital, and a payout the underlying assets cannot sustain shows up as NAV erosion over time — the big yield number is not free.

Income calculator

See how much monthly income a hypothetical investment would generate in each ETF at current yields.

ETFs186
Total AUM$2.13T

ETFs and AUM reflect what Dividend Vision tracks — the issuer's full lineup may be larger.

State Street Global Advisors (SSGA) is one of the largest ETF providers globally, known for pioneering broad-based index and sector exposure through its SPDR product family. Their lineup spans multiple strategies including traditional index funds, income-focused offerings, factor-based approaches, ESG solutions, thematic investments, commodities, bonds, and alternatives, serving both core portfolio building and specialized investment needs. With an extensive range of tickers covering domestic equities, international markets, sector exposure, and fixed income, State Street maintains a comprehensive product ecosystem that appeals to both individual and institutional investors seeking diversified ETF options.

See our curated list of related YouTube videos on SPY.

ETFs20
Total AUM$35.6B

ETFs and AUM reflect what Dividend Vision tracks — the issuer's full lineup may be larger.

NEOS is known for developing specialized income-focused ETFs that employ strategies like covered calls, hedging, and enhanced yields across various asset classes. NEOS distinguishes itself in the ETF landscape through its emphasis on income generation and downside protection strategies rather than traditional growth approaches.

See our curated list of related YouTube videos on SPYI.

Quick verdict

SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust) and SPYI (NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF) are both dividend ETFs, but they take different approaches.

SPYI offers the higher yield at 12.11% vs 1.03% for SPY. A higher yield means more current income per dollar invested, though it may come with different risk characteristics.

SPY is cheaper with an expense ratio of 0.0945% compared to 0.68%.

SPY is the larger fund by assets ($785B), but assets alone do not establish trading costs or liquidity.

Who should choose each?

Choose SPY

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust

  • Want simple, diversified core exposure as a portfolio building block.
  • Want to keep costs low — a 0.0945% expense ratio vs 0.68% for SPYI.

Choose SPYI

NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF

  • Want to maximize current income — SPYI distributes roughly 12.11% from selling options premium, vs 1.03% for SPY.
  • Are comfortable with an options-income strategy — a large payout in exchange for capped upside.
  • Prefer lower market sensitivity — a beta of 0.67 vs 0.97 for SPY.

Not sure? Use the income calculator and snapshot above to weigh these trade-offs against your own goals.

Top-holdings overlap

Positions that appear in every fund's top 10. Issuers disclose only the largest weights, so this captures the overlap of the concentrated end of each book — not the full portfolios.

Same underlying security — SPY. Both funds are built on SPY — held directly, wrapped in an options-income overlay, or leveraged/inverse — so their returns are driven by the same security. A low top-holdings overlap below does not mean unrelated exposure, though the option or leverage overlay changes the risk-and-return profile.
9 shared positions
SPY 35.0% of its top-10 weight
SPYI 35.3% of its top-10 weight
PositionSPYSPYI
AAPL Apple Inc.
8.10%
7.92%
MSFT Microsoft Corporation
6.10%
5.98%
NVDA NVIDIA Corporation
5.83%
6.17%
AMZN Amazon.com Inc
3.98%
4.01%
GOOGL Alphabet Inc Class A
2.56%
2.76%
AVGO Broadcom Inc
2.50%
2.51%
GOOG Alphabet Inc Class C
2.06%
2.22%
META Meta Platforms Inc.
2.10%
2.05%
TSLA Tesla Inc
1.73%
1.70%
Holdings as-of dates unavailable · mode DIRECT (top 10)

Deep dive

Yield & income

On a $10,000 investment at current distribution rates, SPY would pay about $103.00 a year (about $25.75 per quarterly distribution), while SPYI would pay about $1,211.00 a year (about $100.92 per monthly distribution).

SPY yield1.03%
SPYI yield12.11%
Annual cash diff on $10K$1,108.00

Cost & efficiency

Over 10 years on $10,000, SPY would cost approximately $95 in fees vs $680 for SPYI (simplified, not compounded). The $585.50 difference may be offset by yield or performance.

SPY ER0.0945%
SPYI ER0.68%

Strategy & risk

SPY tracks S&P 500 Index with a large cap approach, while SPYI tracks S&P 500 Index with an active approach. Beta is 0.97 for SPY and 0.67 for SPYI, making SPYI the less sensitive to market moves of the two by this measure.

SPY beta0.97
SPYI beta0.67

Fund details

SPY is managed by State Street (launched 01/22/1993) with $785B in assets. SPYI is managed by NEOS (launched 08/29/2022) with $12.5B in assets.

SPY AUM$785B
SPYI AUM$12.5B

Frequently asked questions

What is the current distribution rate for SPY and SPYI?

SPY currently distributes 1.03% and SPYI 12.11%, based on fund data updated November 2026. Distribution rate moves with both the payout and the share price, so check the as-of date before relying on either figure.

Is SPY or SPYI better for dividend income?

It depends on your goals. SPYI currently offers the higher distribution yield, which means more income per dollar invested. However, a lower-yield fund may offer better total return or lower volatility. Consider your time horizon and risk tolerance.

What is the difference between SPY and SPYI?

SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust) tracks S&P 500 Index with a large cap approach, while SPYI (NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF) tracks S&P 500 Index with an active approach. They are issued by State Street and NEOS respectively.

Can I hold both SPY and SPYI?

You can, but expect meaningful overlap: 9 of the disclosed top-10 positions are shared (see the holdings-overlap section above). Holding both may double up on the same underlying names rather than diversify.

Is SPY or SPYI safer?

By Dividend Vision's Distribution Safety Score — a rules-based 0–100 estimate of how resilient a distribution looks, where higher is safer — SPY scores 100, SPYI scores 90, so SPY's payout currently looks the more resilient of the two. SPYI has also been less sensitive to market moves (beta 0.67 vs 0.97 for SPY). No score makes an investment risk-free — treat this as a screening signal, not a guarantee, and the leverage, options-income, or crypto caveats flagged on this page apply regardless of score.

Which has lower fees, SPY or SPYI?

SPY has an expense ratio of 0.0945% while SPYI charges 0.68%. Lower fees mean more of your investment returns stay in your pocket over time.

How much income does $10,000 in SPY vs SPYI generate?

At current distribution rates, $10,000 in SPY would pay about $103.00 a year (about $25.75 per quarterly distribution). $10,000 in SPYI would pay about $1,211.00 a year (about $100.92 per monthly distribution).

Which has performed better historically, SPY or SPYI?

SPY has outpaced SPYI over the trailing twelve months, posting a 11.22% total return against 11.10%. The lead holds up over 3 years too: SPY has compounded at 18.99% a year, against 15.40% for SPYI. Figures are total returns: price change plus every distribution reinvested. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

More comparisons to explore

SPY vs SPYI — at a glance

Generated November 14, 2026.

Overview

SPY and SPYI both track the S&P 500, but they pursue radically different income strategies. The gap in their distribution rates—1.03% versus 12.11%—reflects this structural difference: SPY distributes the dividends embedded in the 500 stocks, while SPYI adds call-writing income but caps upside in the process.

How they differ

The core difference is strategy. That distinction drives everything else. SPYI's 12.11% yield is synthetic—built by combining those same dividends with premium collected from writing calls. The math works because call sellers give up stock price appreciation above a strike level in exchange for that premium.

SPY's 0.0945% expense ratio is among the cheapest in the industry; SPYI's 0.68% is higher, reflecting the cost of actively managing the options overlay. AUM tells a different story about scale: SPY holds $785B in assets, dwarfing SPYI's $12.5B, though SPYI has grown substantially since 08/29/2022. Beta hints at the upside cap: SPY's 0.97 beta means it tracks the market tightly, while SPYI's 0.67 beta suggests dampened participation in market rallies—a natural consequence of sold calls.

Who each is best for

SPY: Fits investors seeking broad large-cap market exposure with minimal cost and no constraints on upside participation. Works as a core portfolio holding or a simple alternative to owning individual S&P 500 stocks.

SPYI: Fits investors prioritizing monthly cash flow over capital appreciation, comfortable with capped upside in exchange for a high and steady income stream. Designed for portfolios where current income matters more than growth.

Key risks to know

  • NAV erosion at extreme yields. SPYI's 12.11% distribution rate far exceeds the underlying dividend yield of the S&P 500. If call premiums decline or realized volatility falls, the fund may be forced to rely on return-of-capital treatment or NAV decline to sustain payouts.
  • Capped upside from call obligations. Because SPYI sells calls, its returns are truncated during strong market rallies. A 20% jump in the S&P 500 will not translate to a 20% gain in SPYI; the sold calls limit appreciation to the strike price.
  • Volatility and strike selection risk. SPYI's call-writing income depends on implied volatility. In a low-volatility regime, call premiums shrink, reducing the fund's ability to generate its target distribution without eroding principal.
  • Lower market participation reflected in beta. SPYI's 0.67 beta versus SPY's 0.97 reflects structural upside capping. Over extended bull markets, this dampening compounds, and investors forgo the returns SPY captures.
  • Tax efficiency claims require scrutiny. While monthly distributions may be labeled tax-efficient, the actual treatment (qualified dividends, short-term gains, return of capital) depends on market moves and volatility levels. Verify the tax form details before relying on SPYI as a tax-shelter strategy.

Bottom line

If you want broad market participation at minimal cost with no income target, SPY is the straightforward choice. If your priority is generating a high monthly paycheck and you're willing to trade capped upside for that income, SPYI's structure offers a systematic way to harvest call premium. The tradeoff is real: SPYI's 12.11% yield masks a cap on appreciation that SPY never accepts. Past performance does not predict future results, and the sustainability of SPYI's payout level depends on market conditions that may shift.

AI-generated analysis for educational purposes only. Verify important details independently; past performance does not guarantee future results.

Learn the method

The metrics behind this comparison, explained in the Academy.

Continue your research

Tracking requires a free account. Account features · Plans.

These comparisons follow the Dividend Vision methodology.