Alternatives
Best MSTY Alternatives in 2026
Top single-stock and crypto option-income ETFs to consider alongside or instead of YieldMax MSTR Option Income (MSTY).
Data updated September 2026 · 12 ETFs
Who this page is for
Best for
- MSTY holders who want to diversify away from single-stock (MSTR) concentration risk
- High-yield seekers comfortable with extreme volatility and NAV erosion
- Investors treating option-income ETFs as a small, actively-monitored satellite sleeve
Not a fit for
- Conservative or income-dependent investors — these funds can erode principal fast
- Anyone who wants the underlying stock's upside; the overlay caps it hard
- Buy-and-forget investors — these require watching NAV trends and return-of-capital levels
Analysis
MSTY alternatives in this category are dominated by single-stock and thematic option-income ETFs, most employing covered-call or synthetic-covered-call strategies to generate high current income. Of the 12 funds tracked, YieldMax supplies the vast majority of names shown in the top 10 here, with NEOS and Simplify ETFs rounding out the issuer landscape. Weekly distributions are the norm among the YieldMax lineup, while NEOS's BTCI stands out in the top 10 here as the sole monthly-pay fund, reflecting a structural difference in how these issuers approach payout cadence.
AI-generated analysis — AI can make mistakes. Verify important information independently. Not investment advice. AI risk disclosure
Risks specific to this category
- Strategy mismatch: several funds on this list track a different index or use a different income mechanism than MSTY, so swapping into one changes the exposure — upside participation, payout cadence, and tax character can all shift, not just the ticker.
- Capped upside: covered-call and option-overlay funds in this group keep the option premium in a rally but surrender gains above the strike, so they can trail the very index they write options against.
- Distribution sustainability: the average distribution rate here is 42.8%, and payouts at that level often include return of capital — when distributions persistently exceed total return, NAV erodes and shrinks the base that generates future income.
- Single-name concentration: option-income funds built on one underlying stock inherit that company's full drawdown risk, and a sharp decline can overwhelm months of option premium.
- Expense drag: expense ratios in this group average 1.14% — several times what broad index funds charge — and that cost compounds directly against total return.
See this list inside your portfolio
A ranked list is a starting point. Dividend Vision turns it into a plan — forecasting the income your holdings actually generate and putting each fund's yield next to its total return and risk.
- Income forecasting — know what your holdings pay monthly, quarterly, and yearly
- Yield vs. total return — weigh each distribution against price performance, not the headline rate
- Screen & compare — line up any income ETFs side by side on yield, cost, and strategy
- Portfolio risk — see income concentration, issuer overlap, and volatility across your holdings
- AI ETF comparison — ask plain-language questions to compare yield, risk, and income potential
7 days of Pro included · no credit card · free plan afterward
How these alternatives are selected
- Universe: a hand-curated peer set, split into close peers (6 here — same core exposure and same income mechanism, so a like-for-like swap) and broader substitutes (a different index, underlying asset, or income mechanism). Every fund is labelled in the Strategy fit column; MSTY itself is excluded.
- Eligibility: active ETFs only — liquidated, delisted, and renamed funds drop out automatically. Leveraged and inverse products are never listed: a daily-reset 2x or -1x fund is not an alternative to a long income position.
- Ranking: assets under management, used only as a fund-size ranking. Never ranked by yield — yields are shown as data, not used to order the list.
- Fit: how each fund's strategy differs from MSTY — and who each one suits — is covered in the strategy notes and FAQ below.
Top picks
Top 3 MSTY alternatives by assets under management.
Yield distribution
Expense ratio distribution
Income projection
Estimated income if the current average distribution rate of 42.84% held for a full year with share prices unchanged. Distribution rate is not total return—a fund can pay a large distribution while its share price falls—so treat these as an upper-bound illustration, not a forecast.
| Investment | Annual income | Monthly income | Weekly income |
|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | $4,284 | $357 | $82 |
| $25,000 | $10,710 | $893 | $206 |
| $50,000 | $21,421 | $1,785 | $412 |
| $100,000 | $42,842 | $3,570 | $824 |
Issuer breakdown
Distribution of ETFs by fund issuer, showing how concentrated or varied the sponsor lineup is.
All 12 ETFs
| Ticker | Name | Strategy fit | Issuer | Yield | Expense ratio | AUM | Frequency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NVDY | YieldMax NVDA Option Income Strategy ETF | Close peer | YieldMax | 36.94% | 1.09% | $1.4B | Weekly |
| BTCI | NEOS Bitcoin High Income ETF | Broader substitute | NEOS | 26.27% | 0.98% | $1.3B | Monthly |
| ULTY | YieldMax Ultra Option Income Strategy ETF | Broader substitute | YieldMax | 59.81% | 1.30% | $721M | Weekly |
| TSLY | YieldMax TSLA Option Income Strategy ETF | Close peer | YieldMax | 49.67% | 1.07% | $678M | Weekly |
| PLTY | YieldMax PLTR Option Income Strategy ETF | Close peer | YieldMax | 33.33% | 1.07% | $371M | Weekly |
| YMAX | YieldMax Universe Fund of Option Income ETFs | Broader substitute | YieldMax | 39.53% | 1.33% | $369M | Weekly |
| CONY | YieldMax COIN Option Income Strategy ETF | Close peer | YieldMax | 74.61% | 1.04% | $340M | Weekly |
| YMAG | YieldMax Magnificent 7 Fund of Option Income ETFs | Broader substitute | YieldMax | 30.80% | 1.34% | $295M | Weekly |
| AMZY | YieldMax AMZN Option Income Strategy ETF | Close peer | YieldMax | 25.43% | 1.09% | $228M | Weekly |
| SMCY | YieldMax SMCI Option Income Strategy ETF | Close peer | YieldMax | 65.74% | 1.01% | $143M | Weekly |
| YBIT | YieldMax Bitcoin Option Income Strategy ETF | Broader substitute | YieldMax | 67.86% | 1.02% | $46M | Weekly |
| MAXI | Simplify Bitcoin Strategy PLUS Income ETF | Broader substitute | Simplify ETFs | 4.11% | 1.31% | $33M | Monthly |
Frequently asked questions
What are the best msty alternatives?
This page lists the top 12 ETFs in this category ranked by key metrics. The list includes funds from issuers like YieldMax, NEOS and more.
How often is this list updated?
The data on this page is refreshed regularly using the latest available distribution rates, expense ratios, and AUM figures. Last updated September 2026.
What is the average yield of these ETFs?
The average distribution yield across the 12 ETFs on this list is 42.84%. Individual yields range from 4.11% to 74.61%.
What is the best alternative to MSTY?
For diversification within the same strategy, CONY, NVDY, and TSLY run MSTY's exact option-income approach on Coinbase, Nvidia, and Tesla. To avoid single-stock risk entirely, ULTY and YMAX hold baskets of these funds, and MAXI or BTCI offer Bitcoin income without tying it to one company's stock.
Why look for an MSTY alternative?
Concentration. MSTY's return depends entirely on one very volatile stock (MSTR), so its NAV can swing violently. Spreading across several single-stock income ETFs — or using a diversified fund-of-funds like YMAX/ULTY — reduces the risk that one company's decline wipes out a large share of your income and principal.
Do MSTY alternatives also erode in value?
Most do. Like MSTY, these funds fund large distributions partly through return of capital and cap the underlying's upside, so their NAV can grind lower over time — especially if the underlying stock falls. A high yield does not offset a declining NAV; always evaluate total return, not the distribution rate alone.
Explore more
Learn the method
The metrics and risks behind this list, explained in the Academy.
From the blog
Put this list to work in your portfolio
Import or build a portfolio to see income forecasts, upcoming distributions, income concentration, and risk across everything you own — and where a fund's yield and total return diverge.
7 days of Pro included · no credit card · free plan afterward